Lauren Malloy is go to New York takes place after Brianna's Killer from her Childhood. Hayley and Hayley Mitchell go to New York to John Milton's friend who let John rape Maureen. Lauren Malloy is in New York and Hayley, Brianna, Missy and Hayley Mitchell need Leon's help to stop Lauren. Brianna and Missy learn that their mothers were friends with Maureen Prescott and Lauren kidnapped them.
- Georgie Henley as Hayley McDonald/Lauren Malloy
- Mark Wahlberg as Leon Brookes
- Natasha Henstridge as Chloe Brooks
- Caitlin Carmichael as Hayley Mitchell/Katie Brooks
- Isabella Acres as Rosie Brooks
- Isaiah Washington as Rick Todd/John's friend
- Ellen Wroe as Brianna Albertson
- Dakota Fanning as Missy Gibson
- Cameron Diaz as Hannah Albertson
- Wendy Kaplan as Kate Gibson
- Lance Henriksen as John Milton
- Lynn McRee as Maureen Prescott
Maureen Prescott and John Milton was seen when Hayley McDonald saw when Maureen was raped by Maureen in the video when a man (Later in the movie, Hayley found out Leon send the video to Hayley when Hayley and Hayley Mitchell was look John's friend) send the video to Hayley.